by Leslie Jordan
I have been writing songs for 18 years. Six and half years ago I started writing songs for the church. I was a part of a broken and beautiful community of people looking for songs that connected us to God: songs of lament, songs of confession, songs of joy, and songs of praise. I quickly realized that when writing songs for a community, there is beauty when writing them in community.
I had never heard the term “co-writing” until I moved to Nashville in college. I had only ever written alone and didn’t know a song could be written with someone else. It seemed scary and vulnerable, and not for me. That is, until I tried it.
My hope today is to share the process I’ve come to know and love when co-writing songs for the church.
• Believe in your own story
• Know your Co-Writers
• Find your shared truth
• Release your ideas
• Connect to biblical truth
• Surrender your song to God
Believe in your own story
When I first began co-writing, I was scared to death. I didn’t think that my ideas or story would be worth sharing. I struggled with the fear that “I am not good enough.”
Henri Nouwen says this in his book Discernment;
“What is the greatest temptation? I wonder if [it] is self-rejection…My dark side says, ‘I am not good. I deserve to be pushed aside, forgotten, rejected, and abandoned.’ Self-rejection is the greatest enemy of the spiritual life because it contradicts the sacred voice that calls us God’s beloved. Being the beloved expresses the core truth of our existence.”
Before you walk into any collaboration, you must know that what God has given you – your story, your heart, your soul, your convictions – belongs to no one else. The truths you share about God may be universal but the way you experience them is specific to you and how He created you. Walk in that reality!
Know your co-writers
If you feel insecure, chances are your co-writer feels the same way. Spend time getting to know each other’s story. Ask questions, be a good listener, and share from experience. If your co-writer happens to be someone you know intimately, spend time catching up on life. Share what God is teaching you or how you’ve seen him move lately. Create a safe place for one another and anticipate that God speaks through our stories. Then spend time talking about your church. If these songs are for your people, they have to be created from a place of knowing their needs. In what season is your church? Lament? Celebration? Confession? Proclamation? What song do you need to sing as a congregation? These questions will quickly lead you into the next step of the process.
Find your Shared Truth
A few years ago we wrote with Paul Baloch. Paul is a pioneer of church music with a pastor’s heart. We didn’t know Paul before our songwriting session with him so we spent a good bit of time getting to know each other. It was beautiful and natural and by the end we felt like old friends. I remember sharing with Paul that our church was in a season of lament but that we were emerging on the other side. We had spent several years acknowledging our brokenness and allowing God to work through that. As we grew and healed, we felt that God was ushering us into a new season of trusting and delighting in Him. Paul immediately said, “I feel the same thing for my community. As I was driving here this morning, the sun cracked the edge of dawn and I was overwhelmed by God’s beauty and goodness. When we behold God, we move beyond our fears and into His light and promise.” This was our shared truth. Sometimes it won’t come that naturally. You may have to work to find it. But I believe that it always emerges. God tends to speak similar things to those he brings together. And if you find that nothing similar emerges, then perhaps move on to the next step of releasing your ideas.
Release Your Ideas
This can be the scariest step in the co-writing process. Maybe you’ve had a melody for 5 years and never shared it with anyone. Maybe you wrote a prayer in your journal when you were alone with God and it is vulnerable to share something so intimate. Perhaps God has something on your heart for your church to hear that is convicting and to share it means facing that reality in your own life. Whatever the hesitation, know that you are not alone. Every artist struggles with letting go of an idea. Once we found our shared truth with Paul, he stood up and grabbed his guitar. He started playing a G chord and said, “As I took in the sunrise the only word I could hear was, Behold!” He began singing a melody and singing “We behold! We behold!” That must have been incredibly vulnerable for Paul. And I’ll admit, I was impressed with his boldness. His willingness to release his idea made it easy to engage and begin sharing mine.
Connect Biblical Truth
As you can imagine, when Paul Baloche is wandering around the room singing a melody, you get caught up in the moment. He was singing words like “Majesty” and “Creation.” I remember we grabbed our Bibles and started looking up scriptures about beholding God’s majesty.
Psalm 8
1 O Lord, our Lord,
how majestic is your name in all the earth!
You have set your glory above the heavens.
2 Out of the mouth of babies and infants,
you have established strength because of your foes,
to still the enemy and the avenger.
3 When I look at your heavens, the work of your fingers,
the moon and the stars, which you have set in place,
4 what is man that you are mindful of him,
and the son of man that you care for him?
I have found that there “is nothing new under the sun.” Lyrics have been written before. Almost every melody belongs to another song. So how do we find the right voice for our songs? I believe the answer lies in scripture. God has given us His words for the church to sing. As songwriters, we have been given a gift! And we must use it. Don’t be afraid to sing the psalms. That is their purpose.
Surrender Your Song to God
Perhaps the most important step of this songwriting process is the last one. David Leonard (with whom I write often) shares this thought in almost every co-writing session; “This song belongs to God and this moment. If He chooses to use it beyond this moment, that is up to Him. But for us right now, let it be a song that brings joy to our hearts and worship to our Creator.” When we find ourselves asking, “will people sing this?” or “is this good enough?” the thought of surrender almost inevitably releases the pressure to know the end of the story. I remember when we finished writing Oh Our Lord we sang it together. Three voices singing our story back to God. It was the story of a new day – of His mercies and glory. We sang about overcoming darkness with the power of the name of God. It was a moment I will never forget.
___________________________
I have experienced great beauty in collaboration and in sharing my story and exploring truth with other songwriters. I hope and pray that these thoughts are an encouragement in writing songs for you and your family!